When appellate judges step out of the courtroom and into a law school lecture hall, the exchange is rarely just ceremonial. A recent visit by judges of the Court of Appeal for Ontario to Western University's Faculty of Law, the first such visit in 12 years, offered a rare window into how appellate judges think about decision-making and advocacy. The same week's Canadian legal news, from a sharply focused restrictive covenant ruling to a certified pandemic-era class action and a debate over employment equity in Alberta, shows why that window matters for practitioners.
Judges in the Classroom: Why the Western Visit Matters
According to the report on the visit, the Ontario appellate judges took part in a judicial outreach program that let students and faculty engage with them directly on judicial decision-making and advocacy.
Why Outreach Is More Than Public Relations
Appellate courts are often the least visible branch of the justice system for students, and for many junior lawyers. Trial proceedings are where most people encounter judges. Appellate reasons, by contrast, are read by specialists, cited in factums, and debated in continuing legal education seminars. Direct contact helps demystify how panels deliberate, what persuades an appellate bench, and why some arguments that look compelling at trial fail on appeal.
The key insight from the visit is that appellate advocacy is learned in part by understanding how judges reason. Exposure to that reasoning before students enter practice narrows the gap between academic training and courtroom expectations.
What Practitioners Can Take Away
- Frame appeals around the standard of review. Judges who explain their approach to decision-making consistently return to whether an error is one of law, mixed fact and law, or palpable and overriding error.
- Write for a panel, not a single reader. Concise, issue-focused factums that anticipate follow-up questions tend to perform better in oral argument.
- Treat mentorship as a pipeline. Law schools that host the bench give students a realistic sense of appellate careers, which feeds into future advocacy and judicial candidacy.
Restrictive Covenants Under the Microscope: The Franchise Non-Compete Ruling
The Ontario Court of Appeal's decision on a fitness franchise agreement, reported in this summary, draws a line that franchise counsel and in-house teams should study closely. The court found the franchisor's non-competition covenant overly broad and unenforceable, yet it upheld the agreement's non-solicitation restrictions.
Why the Distinction Matters
Non-competition and non-solicitation covenants are often drafted in the same clause and treated as interchangeable in commercial negotiations. Courts do not treat them that way. A non-compete restricts a party from carrying on a business or working in a field, which is a far greater restraint on trade. A non-solicit targets a narrower interest, typically the protection of clients, employees, or goodwill. Because restraint of trade is disfavoured, covenants are read against the party seeking to enforce them, and overbreadth can defeat the entire restriction.
Note also that Ontario's statutory ban on employee non-compete agreements, introduced through the Working for Workers Act, 2021, applies to employment relationships. Franchise agreements are commercial arrangements, so covenants in them are generally assessed under common law principles rather than that statutory prohibition. Counsel should not assume the statutory regime settles the question.
Class Actions and Institutional Accountability: The Huron Lodge Certification
Pandemic litigation against long-term care operators has moved from commentary to certification. The Ontario Superior Court of Justice has certified a class action against the Huron Lodge long-term care facility, alleging gross negligence in infection prevention and control. The court found that a class proceeding was the preferable procedure for resolving those claims.
The Preferable Procedure Question
The preferability requirement asks whether a class action is a fair, efficient, and manageable way to advance the claims compared with other options. In mass-harm institutional cases, residents and families often share common questions about policies, staffing, and infection control, which favours aggregate resolution. Defendants, however, will argue that individual circumstances, causation, and damages vary too much for common issues to drive the outcome.
- Identify the common issues early. Frame questions about institutional policies and systemic failures, rather than individual clinical outcomes.
- Build the evidentiary record around the institution. Documents on staffing, protocols, and government directives often carry the most weight.
- Address individual variability head-on. A credible plan for damages and causation can persuade a court that a class proceeding remains manageable.
- Watch for appellate review. Certification rulings in novel pandemic-era claims are likely to be tested as the litigation proceeds.
Bench Capacity and Regional Courts
Ontario Attorney General Doug Downey announced the appointments of Lori Anne Crewe, John Charles Logue Ramsay, and Anna Lorraine Trbovich to the Ontario Court of Justice. The new judges will preside in Pembroke, Cornwall, and Toronto.
Appointments outside the GTA matter for practitioners in two ways. First, they address local backlogs and access to justice in communities where trial dates can stretch. Second, they signal where judicial capacity is being built, which informs practice planning for counsel who appear across multiple jurisdictions. Litigators in eastern Ontario should monitor how the Pembroke and Cornwall dockets evolve.
Employment Equity Under Political Pressure: Alberta's Bill 33
Advocacy groups, including Amnesty International Canada and the National Employment Equity Council, have asked Alberta to withdraw employment equity restrictions in Bill 33. Critics argue the proposed rules would limit public institutions from remedying systemic workplace discrimination.
For employment and human rights counsel, the debate raises a practical question: how far can statutory restrictions reach into voluntary remedial programs? Employers and public bodies relying on equity initiatives should review their programs against any enacted language, and advise clients on the risk of reduced remedial flexibility.
Talent, Mentorship, and Firm Strategy
Firm-level developments this week underline how the profession is building capacity. Vancouver boutique Jiwaji Law added lawyers Priya Parihar and Olivia Armstrong to strengthen commercial litigation, regulatory proceedings, and commercial transactions. MLT Aikins appointed Dr. Rüdiger Tscherning of the University of Calgary Faculty of Law as an academic in residence to support its energy, mining, and natural resources groups. And the 2026 Lexpert Rising Stars Awards recognized leading practitioners aged 40 and under for client advocacy and legal leadership.
Three Patterns Worth Noting
| Development | Practice Area Signal | Practical Implication |
|---|---|---|
| Jiwaji Law hires in litigation and regulatory work | Boutique firms broadening service lines | Expect more niche firms competing on integrated offerings |
| MLT Aikins academic in residence | Energy and natural resources research | Academic partnerships are becoming a differentiator in specialized sectors |
| Rising Stars recognition | Next-generation leadership | Mentorship and visibility are shaping who leads practice groups |
Looking Ahead
The threads connecting these developments are accountability and access. Appellate judges are opening their reasoning to students. Courts are scrutinizing restrictive covenants with greater precision. Institutional defendants face class-wide claims that test how they managed systemic risk. Legislatures are debating whether public bodies can pursue equity remedies. And firms are investing in academic and senior talent to meet clients' changing needs.
For Canadian legal professionals, the practical task is to keep pace across these fronts. Drafting restrictive covenants with precision, building class-wide evidentiary records early, following regional bench appointments, and engaging with law schools and the judiciary will all matter in the months ahead. The profession's next advantage may come less from knowing one area deeply than from understanding how these areas now interact.
